Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for pretending my exam results hadn't arrived because my friend had failed?

AITA category photographAITA

My friend told me she'd failed our final course exam. When she asked how I'd done, I said my result hadn't arrived yet. I'd passed, and I knew.

We had revised together for weeks. She was upset and talking about whether she could face another attempt. I didn't want my good news sitting in the middle of that conversation, so I said I'd let her know when I heard.

Then I kept putting it off. For more than a week, she asked once or twice whether I was still waiting. I said yes. Eventually our tutor congratulated me while we were all packing up after a course social, and she realized I'd known.

She says the failure was embarrassing enough without discovering that I thought she couldn't cope with someone else's success. I said I was trying to give her space, and she replied that I could have done that without lying to direct questions.

I hadn't announced my result in the group chat either, so this wasn't a plan to celebrate with everyone except her. But I was quietly celebrating with my family.

AITA for trying to delay the news until she'd had time to feel better?

Discussion

5 community replies

YTA for the repeated lie. You didn't just postpone an announcement; you gave false answers when she asked.

“I panicked because I didn't know how to say I passed while you were hurting. Then I made it worse by keeping the lie going.” That would tell her what happened without asking her to agree that lying was the considerate choice. Let her decide when she wants to discuss exams again.

Your result deserved some celebration too. Letting yourself enjoy it with family wasn't a betrayal of her. You can be pleased for yourself and sad for your friend without making either feeling cancel the other.

I don't think friends owe instant announcements of every achievement. Sometimes it's considerate to wait rather than place good news into a difficult conversation.

Waiting to announce it would have been fine. Here she asked directly, and then asked again. The issue is the invented missing result, which also left her looking unaware when the tutor spoke.

Join the discussion

More in AITA