Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for not eating the cake my aunt made because she used honey?

AITA category photographAITA

My aunt put a slice in front of me and said she'd made the cake vegan especially for my visit. Then she mentioned the honey she'd used to sweeten it.

I thanked her for the effort and said I don't eat honey. She'd replaced the eggs and dairy and hadn't realised honey was something I avoided too. I explained that it wasn't an allergy; it was part of how I choose to eat. The Vegan Society's explanation of honey places it outside its definition of veganism.

She said I could make one exception because she had tried so hard. I didn't take a bite. My cousin says I could have appreciated the gesture by eating a small piece instead of making my aunt feel she'd failed at welcoming me.

I haven't accused her of doing it deliberately, and I don't want another cake made for me. AITA for keeping my usual choice when the mistake was an affectionate one?

Discussion

5 community replies

NTA. You can appreciate the effort without eating something you've chosen to avoid. An allergy isn't the only reason a food preference or ethical choice can matter to the person eating.

Your aunt made a genuine attempt and missed an ingredient. Keep your response about that particular misunderstanding, rather than turning the cake into a verdict on whether she respects you.

It may help to name the work you noticed: she thought about your visit and changed the eggs and dairy. That thanks doesn't need to be conditional on tasting the finished cake.

If she wants to bake for another visit, offer to choose a recipe together. Ask first, rather than sending a corrective reading list after dinner.

And don't make a second cake the price of putting this behind you. She can accept the information, you can keep thanking her for the welcome, and future dessert can be something you arrange together or bring yourself.

Join the discussion

More in AITA