Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for letting our plans fall through to see whether my friend would remember?

AITA category photographAITA

We'd agreed to meet at the park on Sunday at eleven. Usually I send a message that morning. This time I didn't.

I'm tired of being the person who checks every plan is still happening. I wanted to see whether she'd remember without me starting the conversation.

When eleven came and I still hadn't heard from her, I stayed home. Later she admitted she'd forgotten. I said that proved we only met because I did the work.

She says forgetting was her mistake, but I hadn't kept the plan either. If she'd simply turned up without messaging, I wouldn't have been there. I said that wasn't what happened; she had forgotten.

Now she's apologised for missing it, but wants me to acknowledge that I was setting a test instead of telling her how tired I was of organising us. AITA for stopping the reminders for once?

Discussion

5 community replies

Stopping reminders would have been reasonable. Staying home because she hadn't sent one changed the test: you treated silence as proof the meeting wasn't happening before you knew she'd forgotten.

Her forgetting is real, and she should own it. It doesn't prove every plan would fail without you. One missed meeting can't supply the whole account of how much each of you contributes.

You could have gone to the park and held her responsible for the actual no-show. Instead, you also decided not to attend. Don't use what you learned afterwards to pretend you knew it at eleven.

Tell her you want her to initiate and confirm some plans, with specific examples of what feels uneven. That gives her a chance to respond to a request instead of an experiment she didn't know she was in.

And make the next arrangement clear enough that neither person has to guess whether a missing check-in cancels it. Sharing the organising should reduce the hidden work, not create a new guessing game.

Join the discussion

More in AITA