Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for lending our shared console to my brother without asking my partner?

AITA category photographAITA

I told my partner the console would be back on Sunday. She said she'd invited friends to play on Saturday.

We bought it together. I use it more often, and when my brother asked to borrow it for the weekend, I assumed it wouldn't be missed. I said yes and helped him pack it before checking with her.

She wants me to arrange its return before her friends arrive. I said my brother had already made plans with it too, and that she'd only need to find something else to do for one afternoon.

She replied that those plans weren't mine to rank. Her invitation existed before I created the loan, and using the console less often didn't mean she needed to reserve it with me.

I was trying to do my brother a favour. I now have two people relying on the same thing because I answered as though it were only mine. AITA for asking her to be flexible rather than undoing the loan?

Discussion

5 community replies

YTA for making her absorb the clash you created. The fact that your brother now has plans doesn't make them more established than the plans she already had.

Using it more often doesn't tell you when the other owner intends to use it. A quick question would have mattered precisely because her Saturday wasn't part of your routine.

Tell your brother that you agreed before checking and need to sort out the return. Don't describe it as your partner suddenly refusing to share; she wasn't included in the original decision.

For future loans, agree on whether either of you can say yes alone and under what circumstances. It can be a short household agreement rather than a booking system for every evening.

And if the agreement is to ask first, an unanswered message shouldn't become permission by default. That would leave the same assumption in place with an extra notification attached.

Join the discussion

More in AITA