Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for leaving our hobby choir after the group started booking paid gigs?

AITA category photographAITA

Our choir leader announced that she'd booked us for weekend performances and that we'd split the payments between the singers. I said I'd leave after the next regular rehearsal.

I joined when we met on weekday evenings to sing for fun. We occasionally sang for friends at the end of rehearsal, which I enjoyed. The new plan involves travel, public performances and extra practice. Most of the group is excited. I don't want my hobby to turn into that kind of commitment, even with payment.

The leader had talked about trying gigs, but hadn't asked each of us to confirm before making the bookings. I hadn't said I'd sing at them. Now she says the arrangements depend on the voices we already have, and losing me means extra work before the first performance.

She asked me to stay until they found a replacement. I offered to return my music and attend the next rehearsal to help go through my part, but didn't agree to an open-ended search. She said I was leaving just as our practice was finally leading somewhere.

For me, the ordinary rehearsals already were the thing I wanted. I know my departure still creates work for people who weren't trying to upset me. AITA for leaving before the gigs begin?

Discussion

5 community replies

NTA. A choir can be successful as a place where people enjoy a weekday evening. The leader can want public gigs, and you can decide that her new direction isn't the hobby you joined for.

Your voice being useful doesn't mean your availability was confirmed. Still, tell her clearly which rehearsal will be your last so nobody builds another arrangement around a vague possibility that you'll stay.

If you enjoy the group, you could ask whether there is room for rehearsal-only members. That's an option to explore if you want it, not a duty to keep attending while everyone practises for performances you won't be doing.

The leader may have read the group's excitement as agreement from everyone. I'd explain your own reasons without arguing that she was wrong to want gigs. “This sounds good for the group, but it isn't what I want to spend my weekends doing” is enough.

It can be good for most of the group and still have been booked too soon. She needed individual answers before relying on a particular set of singers. You don't have to turn your exit into a fight about ambition to point that out.

Join the discussion

More in AITA