Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for leaving one ingredient out of the family recipe I gave my sister?

AITA category photographAITA

My sister made our grandmother's mushroom pie three times before asking why it never tasted like mine. I admitted I'd left an ingredient out of the recipe I sent her.

It wasn't an accident. Since Grandma died, I've been the one who brings that pie to family meals. Being asked to make it makes me feel useful and connected to her. When my sister wanted the recipe for a dinner at her own home, I worried it wouldn't be “my thing” anymore.

I sent almost everything and left out a spoonful of mustard. When she said the first attempt tasted different, I suggested trying a different batch of mushrooms. I knew that wasn't the explanation.

She isn't angry that I wanted one dish to be special to me. She's angry that I let her keep trying and buying ingredients while pretending I'd given her the whole recipe. I sent the corrected version and offered to replace what she'd used. She said she didn't want a grocery refund; she wanted to know why I'd rather watch her struggle than tell her the truth.

AITA for trying to keep one little family role for myself?

Discussion

5 community replies

YTA. Keeping a recipe private and sending a deliberately incomplete one are different choices. The second made her waste time trying to fix a problem you had created.

The advice about different mushrooms is where this became more than one insecure decision. She gave you a chance to correct the omission, and you supplied another false explanation instead.

Tell her the part you told us: you were afraid of losing a connection to Grandma. That may help her understand you. It won't require her to agree that misleading her was a reasonable way to protect it.

Having a signature dish can matter. The narrator needn't give up being the person who brings it to family meals just because the sister can now cook it.

Sharing the recipe doesn't settle who brings which dish to a gathering. A conversation about keeping that family role could help. The narrator tried instead to preserve it by secretly limiting what their sister could make elsewhere.

Join the discussion

More in AITA