Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for leaving a date after she brought her best friend without telling me?

AITA category photographAITA

I arrived for our first dinner date and found her best friend at the table too.

We'd met online and agreed to meet at a busy restaurant. She said her friend was there to help her feel comfortable and would probably stay for the meal. I hadn't been told before arriving.

I said I understood wanting support, but I'd come for a date between the two of us. She suggested we order and see how it went. I said I'd rather leave and arrange something else if she wanted. Then I left before anyone ordered.

She later messaged that walking out made her feel punished for being cautious. I said I would have considered a group meeting if we'd discussed it first. She replied that I could have managed one dinner without making it a principle.

I wasn't angry with her friend and didn't ask either of them to leave. I just didn't want the evening we now had. AITA for ending it there rather than giving the three-person dinner a chance?

Discussion

5 community replies

NAH about wanting different kinds of first meetings. She can want her friend present, and you can decline that arrangement. Telling you before you arrived would have saved everyone an awkward evening.

You offered another meeting instead of demanding that she send her friend away. That's a relevant difference. She didn't have to accept the offer, but your leaving wasn't automatically a punishment.

Did “arrange something else” mean another one-on-one dinner, or were you open to a short group meeting first? If you actually want to keep talking, make the alternative concrete. Otherwise it may have sounded like a polite exit line.

I'd probably have stayed for a drink. Finding out whether the conversation worked might have been worth a little flexibility.

That would have been a kind option, but it wasn't the only decent one. They hadn't ordered, and the narrator explained the mismatch. Neither person needs to turn an incompatible first meeting into proof of bad character.

Join the discussion

More in AITA