Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for keeping the icing flower from my birthday cake for myself?

AITA category photographAITA

Before we cut the cake, I put the big icing flower on my plate. My niece asked for it, and I said I was keeping that bit.

I'd chosen the cake partly because of the flower. Everyone got a slice, including my niece. My sister says an adult should let a child have the decorative piece instead of reserving it like a prize.

I said it was my birthday and I'd been looking forward to it. She replied that I was making a four-year-old watch me eat the part she wanted.

I didn't wave it around or tease her. I also didn't offer to split it. AITA for keeping a small birthday treat when giving it away would have made a child happy?

Discussion

5 community replies

NTA. You shared the cake. Wanting one particular piece on your own birthday doesn't mean the child was denied a celebration or a slice.

Your sister could have acknowledged her daughter's disappointment without turning it into an accusation against you. Not every wanted decoration has to become available because a younger person asks.

Splitting it would have been generous if you wanted to. That doesn't make refusing the split automatically ungenerous after you'd already served everyone cake.

The useful question for next time is whether you want a special bit reserved before people choose slices. You'd done that here; changing the rule only after someone wanted it would make the reservation fairly meaningless.

And you don't need to order extra decorations for every possible disappointment next year. That could be a fun choice, but it isn't a repair you owe for eating the flower you chose.

Join the discussion

More in AITA