Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for keeping my coffee separate when I use our shared kitchen basics?

AITA category photographAITA

I moved my coffee into my own cupboard and told my flatmates it wasn't part of the shared supplies.

We normally share oil, tea and basic seasonings without keeping a tally. I'd bought a bag of coffee I especially liked and left it by the kettle. People used it. I hadn't labelled it or said anything beforehand.

When it ran down quickly, I said everyone should replace what they'd taken. They said they'd treated it the way I treated their tea and cooking oil. I replied that this coffee was a personal treat, not a kitchen staple.

They say that's a distinction I invented only once I saw how much had gone. I've dropped the request for replacement, but still plan to keep future bags for myself while continuing the shared arrangement for the usual basics.

AITA for drawing that line after benefiting from the less formal system?

Discussion

5 community replies

Keeping future coffee separate sounds reasonable. Asking people to replace what they used before you stated the difference was the weaker part, and you've already withdrawn that request.

The shared arrangement still needs to feel reciprocal. Check whether your flatmates also have particular items they want to reserve, rather than treating yours as the only personal exception.

“Staple” isn't a sufficiently clear dividing line when tea was shared and coffee sat beside it. You can make a new arrangement without claiming they should have guessed the old one.

A simple conversation about which items are shared will do more than quietly moving the bag and hoping nobody is annoyed. Include the tea and oil you use in that discussion.

And leave room for them to prefer less sharing overall. You can ask for a personal coffee shelf, but the household isn't obliged to preserve every other part of the informal system exactly as you liked it.

Join the discussion

More in AITA