Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for keeping a stage role after my partner objected to the scripted kiss?

AITA category photographAITA

My partner asked me to tell the director I couldn't do the kiss in our community play. I said I was keeping the role as written.

The kiss was in the script when I auditioned. I told my partner about it before accepting the part, and he said he thought he'd be fine. We're both adults, as is the actor playing opposite me. There isn't a past relationship or an offstage flirtation involved.

Now that rehearsals have started, my partner says imagining it and knowing it will happen are different. He asked whether the director could stage the scene without a kiss. I haven't asked. I like the scene as written, and I don't want my first response to his discomfort to be renegotiating the role.

He says I'm treating the production as more important than him, especially since we don't know whether a change would even be difficult. I said acting sometimes includes romantic scenes, and I don't want to need his approval for each one. He replied that he'd tried to be comfortable and was telling me honestly that he wasn't.

The cast has already spent time rehearsing, though the performance is still weeks away. AITA for keeping the role without first asking about an alternative?

Discussion

5 community replies

His earlier answer matters, but it doesn't mean he's barred from discovering that he's uncomfortable. You can listen seriously to that without promising to remove the kiss. “You already agreed” won't get you very far if the real issue is what each of you can live with now.

I'd keep the role. You disclosed what it involved before accepting, and you want to perform it. A partner can tell you that something hurts without automatically getting control over the decision that follows.

The strongest part of his argument is that you haven't explored the option he's suggested. You may still decide you don't want a change, but say that plainly. Don't use the cast's rehearsal time as the whole explanation when your own artistic preference is also part of it.

Don't bring the director a request you're unwilling to make. That could pull the production into resolving a couple's disagreement. First decide whether you personally want to ask about changing the scene, rather than asking so you can report back that you tried.

That's fair, although a conversation about options doesn't have to promise a change. The important part is being honest with both people: don't tell your partner the director refused if you never asked, and don't tell the director you're personally uncomfortable if the concern is your partner's.

Join the discussion

More in AITA