Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for keeping a list of gift ideas for my partner?

AITA category photographAITA

My partner asked how I'd remembered the exact edition of a book she wanted. I showed her the note on my phone. She stopped smiling.

The note is a list of things she's mentioned liking: the book, a particular colour of scarf, a museum she'd like to visit. I add an idea when it comes up and look at the list before birthdays. I thought showing her would make it clear that I listen.

She says it makes our conversations feel like research and that she'd rather I remembered what mattered without keeping records. I said the list was how I remembered. Then I called her reaction ungrateful, which I regret.

She isn't asking me to return the book. She wants me to stop adding to the note and choose future presents more spontaneously. I don't want to agree, forget something lovely she mentioned, and then disappoint her for that instead.

AITA for wanting to keep the list after she's told me it bothers her?

Discussion

5 community replies

The list sounds attentive. Remembering with a note is still remembering something she said. Calling her ungrateful was the part that turned a difference in how you understand romance into an accusation.

I can see why discovering the list took some surprise out of the gift. But expecting all the same accuracy with none of the memory aid isn't a very workable replacement. Ask what actually feels uncomfortable about the entries.

Let her say if a particular item was a passing comment rather than a wish. A gift list can help you notice things without becoming a standing order you assume she's placed.

The book doesn't need to become evidence in an argument about which of you understands thoughtfulness. Tell her why you were excited to find it, and apologise for the insult separately from discussing the note.

Agreed. An apology for calling her ungrateful wouldn't mean the list was wrong. You can take care with her disappointment without pretending your method involved less affection.

Join the discussion

More in AITA