AITA for keeping a list of gift ideas for my partner?
AITAMy partner asked how I'd remembered the exact edition of a book she wanted. I showed her the note on my phone. She stopped smiling.
The note is a list of things she's mentioned liking: the book, a particular colour of scarf, a museum she'd like to visit. I add an idea when it comes up and look at the list before birthdays. I thought showing her would make it clear that I listen.
She says it makes our conversations feel like research and that she'd rather I remembered what mattered without keeping records. I said the list was how I remembered. Then I called her reaction ungrateful, which I regret.
She isn't asking me to return the book. She wants me to stop adding to the note and choose future presents more spontaneously. I don't want to agree, forget something lovely she mentioned, and then disappoint her for that instead.
AITA for wanting to keep the list after she's told me it bothers her?