Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for keeping a critical review online after the shop refunded me?

AITA category photographAITA

The shop owner asked me to remove my review because I'd received a refund. I added the refund to it, but didn't delete the original account.

I'd ordered an item that never arrived and had struggled to get an answer. My review described the order and the unanswered messages. After the refund, I added a dated update saying the money had been returned and the issue was resolved.

The owner says a small shop shouldn't keep carrying a public complaint once it's put things right. She isn't asking me to call the service excellent, just to take down a review that still begins with the bad experience.

I don't think the refund means the weeks before it didn't happen. But I also know an update at the end may not be the first thing someone notices.

AITA for keeping the review with the correction instead of deleting it?

Discussion

5 community replies

Keeping an accurate account with a clear resolution sounds reasonable. A refund addressed the missing order; it didn't give you a different experience of the unanswered messages.

Your own concern about where the update appears is worth acting on. If you want the review to describe the whole experience, put the resolution somewhere readers can readily see it rather than burying it after the complaint.

The owner can ask you to reconsider without that obliging you to erase the account. You can recognise the effort to resolve it and still think the earlier service is relevant.

Consider what you want the review to do now: describe your experience, warn that a problem remains, or express continuing anger. Only the first matches your statement that the issue is resolved.

That's a useful distinction. Don't leave wording that suggests you're still waiting for the item or the refund. You can keep the history without preserving an outdated impression of the present.

Join the discussion

More in AITA