Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for keeping a charity raffle prize instead of donating it back?

AITA category photographAITA

When my number was called, I went up to collect the hamper. My aunt whispered that I should offer it back for another draw.

She helps organise the fundraiser. I bought tickets, helped set out chairs and hadn't been told winners were expected to return prizes. She says several winners have done that in previous years because the point is raising money, not taking things home.

I said I'd already contributed and wanted to keep what I'd won. She replied that I could afford my own hamper and that offering it back would have been an easy public gesture of support.

I took it home. Now she says she felt embarrassed standing beside me while I accepted congratulations as though this were an ordinary competition.

I don't know whether anyone else actually expected me to return it. AITA for keeping the prize rather than following a tradition I learned about at the moment I won?

Discussion

5 community replies

NTA. If prizes are only ceremonial until winners offer them back, that expectation should have been explained before the draw. Your aunt's preferred gesture isn't automatically the bargain you entered.

She may have been hoping for another generous moment at an event she cares about. That makes the disappointment understandable. It doesn't mean the chairs, tickets and other help stopped counting when you took the hamper.

Don't assume the whole room shared her view. Your account establishes what your aunt wanted, not what everyone thought while congratulating you.

You could ask her before next year's event whether she wants a donation, practical help or raffle participation. That would let you choose your contribution without a surprise performance of generosity.

Yes, but the clarification shouldn't become a promise to hand back any future prize. She can explain the custom, and you can decide whether that version of participating appeals to you.

Join the discussion

More in AITA