Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for hiring another painter after telling my brother I'd rather pay family?

AITA category photographAITA

“I'd rather the money go to you,” I told my brother when I asked him to quote for painting my living room. I meant it, until I saw the price.

He runs a small painting business. His quote was more than I had set aside, so I got two others. The one I chose was lower and within my budget. I sent each painter the same description of the work, but I can't personally judge whether they'd put the same care into every step. My brother says his preparation is more thorough.

I told him I was choosing the other painter before agreeing on a start date with anyone. He says I made him spend an evening measuring and writing up a quote for a job I'd practically promised him. He didn't charge for the estimate, and he had told me he would see whether he could fit me in; he hadn't blocked out a week.

I offered to pay him for the time spent quoting. He said that made it feel even more like I'd used him as a price check. I didn't send his quote to the other painters or ask them to beat it.

AITA for saying I preferred to hire him when I wasn't prepared to pay his price?

Discussion

5 community replies

NAH on the choice of painter. Preferring your brother doesn't give you a bigger budget. I can also see why he heard “I'd rather pay family” as a stronger indication than an ordinary request for a quote.

You don't have to prove the cheaper quote buys identical work. You may knowingly choose a different level of preparation within your budget. Avoid turning the family conversation into a judgment that his work can't be worth what he charges.

The offer to pay for his evening was considerate. You don't need to keep proposing payments until one makes him approve.

Did he know your budget before he measured? That would help distinguish a wasted conversation from a straightforward mismatch neither of you spotted early.

That's the detail I'd want too. A stated ceiling would have let him say whether the job was realistic for him. Either way, the repair could be about communicating that ceiling, without reversing the hiring decision.

Join the discussion

More in AITA