Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for giving my cousin chocolates past their best-before date?

AITA category photographAITA

My cousin turned over the birthday chocolates, read the date and handed them back.

We're in England. The sealed box was a week past its best-before date. I'd bought it earlier, kept it as the label instructed and noticed the date before wrapping it. I gave it anyway because it was a variety she'd said she liked.

I sent her the UK food-labelling guidance, which distinguishes best-before quality dates from use-by safety dates. I wasn't claiming I could certify that particular box as safe. I thought the distinction explained why I'd been comfortable giving it.

She says the issue is that I knew the gift was past the manufacturer's quality date and decided she could have it anyway. She doesn't want a lesson in labels instead of a birthday present someone checked.

I offered to replace it, but only after arguing about the date. AITA for giving the box, even if the date didn't mean what she initially thought it meant?

Discussion

5 community replies

The date distinction is real, but it doesn't settle whether this was a thoughtful birthday gift. You saw the date and made the choice for her. She can dislike that choice without needing to prove the chocolates were dangerous.

Offering a replacement was the useful response. Sending the guidance first probably felt as if she had to lose a food-labelling debate before you would acknowledge that the present disappointed her.

A best-before label isn't a guarantee about the condition of an individual box, and nobody here can assess that box. Don't pressure her to eat it to demonstrate that she accepts the difference between date types.

You could say, “I knew the date had passed and thought you'd still enjoy these; I see why that didn't feel like a good gift.” That answers what she is actually upset about.

Yes, and leave out a final “but technically.” You don't have to retract the correct date distinction to admit that using it as your main defence missed the birthday part.

Join the discussion

More in AITA