AITA for giving my cousin chocolates past their best-before date?
AITAMy cousin turned over the birthday chocolates, read the date and handed them back.
We're in England. The sealed box was a week past its best-before date. I'd bought it earlier, kept it as the label instructed and noticed the date before wrapping it. I gave it anyway because it was a variety she'd said she liked.
I sent her the UK food-labelling guidance, which distinguishes best-before quality dates from use-by safety dates. I wasn't claiming I could certify that particular box as safe. I thought the distinction explained why I'd been comfortable giving it.
She says the issue is that I knew the gift was past the manufacturer's quality date and decided she could have it anyway. She doesn't want a lesson in labels instead of a birthday present someone checked.
I offered to replace it, but only after arguing about the date. AITA for giving the box, even if the date didn't mean what she initially thought it meant?