Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for giving away the sourdough starter my mother asked me to keep?

AITA category photographAITA

Mum asked how her starter was doing. I said it was with my neighbour now.

She'd given me a jar when I moved, along with a note saying it came from the starter my grandmother used. I thanked her and said I'd look after it. I liked the idea of being someone who made bread on Sundays. In practice, I didn't enjoy the routine and stopped wanting to bake.

My neighbour did want it, so I handed it over. I thought passing it to someone enthusiastic was better than keeping it out of guilt. I didn't tell Mum beforehand because I knew she'd ask me to try again.

She still has her own jar; I haven't given away the family's only starter. What upset her was that she'd offered me a connection to Grandma and I'd treated it as an unwanted kitchen item. She says I should at least have offered it back.

I said, “It isn't a pet. I don't have to keep it forever.” That made things worse. I don't think a gift should commit me to a hobby, but I had explicitly said I'd care for this one. AITA for passing it on without asking?

Discussion

5 community replies

Passing it to someone who wanted to bake was a reasonable end to a hobby you weren't enjoying. The part I'd apologise for is avoiding the conversation because you knew your mum would object, then dismissing the meaning of her gift when she found out.

She still has the starter herself, so the family connection hasn't disappeared. But you did make a promise, and she learned you'd ended it only because she asked. “I don't want to keep doing this” would have been an uncomfortable but more considerate conversation.

Would your neighbour be happy to give you a small portion for your mum, if your mum actually wants it back? Ask before offering that. Don't turn your neighbour into the person responsible for resolving the family disagreement.

The pet comparison answered a demand your mother hadn't quite made. She asked why you hadn't offered it back. You can acknowledge that missed courtesy without agreeing to feed a jar for the rest of your life.

Yes. “I should have offered it back, and I still don't want to keep a starter” would cover both points. You don't have to resume baking to prove that Grandma matters to you.

Join the discussion

More in AITA