Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for eating dessert before the special dinner my partner was making?

AITA category photographAITA

At half past six I told my partner I probably couldn't manage much of the main course.

He looked at the empty cake plate and said, "You knew I was cooking."

We had planned a special dinner at home. He said it would be ready around six, then told me in the afternoon that it might be closer to seven. I came home hungry at five-thirty and ate a large slice of the cake we'd bought for dessert.

I didn't tell him until he was nearly ready to serve. I thought having a snack while the meal ran later was ordinary. He says I chose the richest part of the planned meal and then left him to put out two portions of something I'd barely touch.

I did sit down with him and ate some of the dinner. He was quiet, and I said I couldn't be expected to stay hungry because cooking took longer than planned. He replied that I could have had a smaller snack or simply told him what I was doing.

I don't want our food choices policed. I also knew this was an evening he was putting effort into for both of us, and I acted as though my appetite was irrelevant until the food reached the table. AITA?

Discussion

5 community replies

Being hungry at five-thirty was reasonable, especially after the expected dinner time moved. The choice wasn't limited to waiting unhappily or eating a large slice of the shared dessert. You had room to consider the dinner he was still making.

The missed communication seems central. Telling him when you ate would at least have let him know you wanted a smaller portion. Keeping quiet until serving made the change another thing he discovered at the end of the work.

His disappointment doesn't automatically mean he wants to control your food. In this account he suggested a smaller snack or notice. Respond to that rather than to a wider rule he hasn't proposed.

The cake was part of the evening you had planned together. Eating it alone first changed more than the size of your appetite; it also changed the sequence he was looking forward to sharing.

That helps explain the reaction without making the meal sacred. The narrator can apologize for not considering the shared plan while still saying they needed something to eat. Next time, a quick conversation would give both people more choices.

Join the discussion

More in AITA