Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for declining to help search after I'd already handed in someone's lost wallet?

AITA category photographAITA

"You know exactly where it was," the owner said. "Could you come back and walk the route with me?"

I'd found her wallet beside a bench outside the library and handed it to the service desk. I left my number in case staff had a question. With my permission, they gave it to her when she collected the wallet.

She called to thank me, then said a small keepsake she usually carried wasn't inside. I told her the time, the bench and which entrance I'd used. I hadn't emptied the wallet or checked every compartment, so I couldn't say what had been there.

She asked me to meet her the next morning to look around. I said I had work and couldn't. She asked about the evening. I said I wasn't available then either, and that I'd given her everything I knew.

I could probably have found half an hour in the evening. I just didn't want the return of one item to become an ongoing assignment. Her voice changed, and she said she'd hoped the person who noticed the wallet would understand why this mattered.

AITA for stopping at the information instead of giving more time to help her search?

Discussion

5 community replies

You handed the wallet in and then supplied the location and time when asked. Those were concrete forms of help. Not being able to account for a keepsake you hadn't inspected isn't evidence that you handled the return carelessly.

Her request wasn't necessarily an attempt to assign you a job. She was looking for something important and thought the person who found the wallet might be useful company. You can decline without turning her hope into a character flaw.

Your work commitment explained the morning. 'Not available' in the evening also communicated a choice about your time, even if you could technically have freed half an hour. You don't need to invent an immovable appointment to have a limit.

Would a clear description of the bench and entrance be enough for someone who hadn't been there with you? If you already supplied that, accompanying her might have added reassurance more than new information.

That seems consistent with what the narrator says they shared. They can acknowledge the loss kindly and repeat that they can't join the search. Compassion doesn't have to include pretending they know whether the keepsake was ever beside the wallet.

Join the discussion

More in AITA