Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for declining to hear my nephew play the same piece a third time?

AITA category photographAITA

My nephew picked up his instrument again and said, “One more time.” I said I'd enjoyed hearing it but wanted to go back to the table.

He's eight and had practised a piece to show us at Sunday lunch. I'd promised to listen. I sat through it once, applauded, then listened again when he wanted to show me a part he'd been pleased with.

When he asked for a third performance, I said no. He looked upset, and my sister asked why I couldn't give him another few minutes after he'd worked so hard. I said listening twice hadn't become nothing just because I didn't want a third turn.

She says I made him feel his enthusiasm was a nuisance. I didn't criticise the playing or tell him not to play for anyone else. I just wanted the visit to include conversation too. AITA?

Discussion

5 community replies

NTA. You kept the promise to listen and gave him another turn as well. Declining a repeat doesn't mean you failed to notice the work he'd done.

Be specific about something you enjoyed if you can honestly say it. “I liked hearing that section you practised” may help the no feel less like a sudden withdrawal of interest.

Your sister is allowed to wish you'd listened longer. She shouldn't erase the attention you already gave by making the third performance the only measure of support.

You could choose another time to listen if you genuinely want to, but don't promise a regular audience just to get through this disagreement. That could make the next no harder for both of you.

Yes. A kind ending is more useful than an invitation you don't mean. You can be happy he wants to share his playing and still say you're returning to lunch now.

Join the discussion

More in AITA