Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for declining to be the executor of my friend's will?

AITA category photographAITA

My friend said he wanted to name me as his executor because I was the person he trusted to get things done. I said I was touched, but I didn't want the role.

We're in England, and he's preparing a will. I read the GOV.UK description of an executor: the person chosen to handle the estate and carry out the wishes in the will. I don't want to promise that future responsibility.

He says I've helped with paperwork before and would handle it better than his relatives. That's probably why he asked. But helping him sort a few letters isn't a commitment to an entire role, at an unknown point in my own life.

He heard my refusal as saying I wouldn't be there when he most needed someone dependable. I offered to sit with him while he wrote down questions for his will writer. He said that was a smaller favor designed to let me feel helpful while avoiding the meaningful one.

I haven't agreed to be named. AITA for refusing before knowing how much work it would actually involve?

Discussion

5 community replies

Taking the request seriously can lead to a no. It would be worse to give him reassurance you don't mean because you feel honored by his trust.

He may have heard “I don't want the role” as “I don't care what happens to your wishes.” Tell him you do care, and that's why you want him to plan around someone who genuinely agrees.

You don't have to accept his ranking of the two offers. Helping him prepare questions is a useful thing if he wants it. It isn't a claim that you've agreed to everything else he needs.

If he's asking because nobody else feels dependable, refusing may leave him with a real problem rather than just hurt feelings.

It may. That makes the decision difficult, but it doesn't make an unwilling promise a dependable solution. He needs to know the narrator's answer while he's making the arrangements, not assume agreement from their history of helping.

Join the discussion

More in AITA