Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for counting audiobooks in our reading challenge when the organizer disagrees?

AITA category photographAITA

I put three completed audiobooks on our club's reading-challenge list. The organizer removed them and said the challenge was about reading.

The invitation said “finish twelve books this season.” It didn't specify print, ebooks, or audio. I've been listening during my commute and joining the discussions about the stories. I wasn't hiding the format; I'd mentioned the narrator of one recording in the chat.

The organizer says listening is a different activity and including it makes the challenge less of a reading habit. I said she could state a format rule for the next challenge, but I didn't think these entries should disappear halfway through this one.

There's no money or prize involved. It's a shared list and a small celebration at the end. Other members have started taking sides, and she says I'm turning a friendly activity into a technical dispute.

AITA for asking her to restore the entries rather than just keeping my own list?

Discussion

5 community replies

The original wording left room for your interpretation. Asking to keep the completed entries is reasonable, especially when you were open about listening.

I'd keep this away from sweeping claims about which format is better. You can discuss what this particular challenge was meant to encourage without judging how everyone enjoys stories.

Ask the group to settle the rule for the remainder of the season and write it down. If nobody can agree, a separate format column could preserve the list without pretending the disagreement has vanished.

The organizer may have wanted people to spend time looking at text. If that's the goal, audio doesn't match the activity she hoped to encourage.

Then that goal needed to be stated. The invitation named completed books rather than time spent with print. She can clarify what she wants to organize next, while recognizing that the narrator followed a reasonable reading of this invitation.

Join the discussion

More in AITA