Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for correcting our quiz score when it meant our team lost the prize?

AITA category photographAITA

"We got two points for that blank answer," I told the host.

Our team had been announced as the winner with twenty-one points, one ahead of the next team. When the marked sheet came back, I noticed an unanswered line had been credited with two points. I took it to the host, who corrected the total. The other team won.

My teammates were annoyed that I hadn't spoken to them first. One said the host had made the error, not us, and another said I had turned a fun evening into a demonstration of my principles.

I said a blank answer wasn't something we could reasonably call correct. They replied that I could at least have let them see the sheet before walking over and giving away the prize we'd just been promised.

I don't think a private team vote should decide whether an obvious scoring mistake gets mentioned. But I did act as though the disappointment would be simple for everyone else just because the arithmetic was simple for me.

AITA for correcting it immediately rather than consulting the people who lost the reward with me?

Discussion

5 community replies

The error was concrete: two points on a blank line changed twenty-one to nineteen. Correcting that didn't require deciding that your teammates had played dishonestly. The host made the mistake; you noticed it.

Showing the team the sheet first could have been a courtesy without offering them a veto over the correction. It would have let them understand what was happening before the announcement changed.

The host's error wasn't the team's fault, but keeping an outcome after discovering the error would have been a separate choice. Your teammates' disappointment can be real without making those two things identical.

'The arithmetic was simple' doesn't mean the loss felt simple. They had just enjoyed being announced as winners. Acknowledging that moment doesn't require agreeing the wrong score should have stayed.

That is probably the useful apology available: for acting as though there was no disappointment to take seriously. The narrator can stand by the correction and still say they should have shown the sheet and explained before walking off.

Join the discussion

More in AITA