Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for closing my free book box after a neighbor started taking books to resell?

AITA category photographAITA

My neighbor told me she sold the stack of books she'd taken from the free box outside my house. I asked her to leave some for other people next time. She said I'd put them out to be taken.

For months I've been adding books I finish to a weatherproof box by my gate. The sign says “Free books—take something you'd enjoy.” It doesn't mention resale, quantities, or bringing anything back. Recently the box has been cleared soon after I fill it. My neighbor says she's taken several stacks and sells what she can to help with her household expenses.

I started the box because I liked the idea of books passing between people nearby. Seeing them offered for sale makes the effort less enjoyable for me. I told her that, and she said I was happy to be generous only while I could decide how people used the gift.

I brought the box inside rather than argue every time I restocked it. She says I'm punishing everyone because she found a use for books I didn't want.

I could put up more rules, but I don't want to monitor a book box. AITA for ending the whole thing over this?

Discussion

5 community replies

The box was an ongoing effort you chose to make. You can stop choosing it when it no longer feels worthwhile.

She has a point about the original sign. It didn't tell her she was taking part in a local exchange rather than receiving unwanted books. I'd avoid treating her first stack as a betrayal of a condition you hadn't stated.

Now that you've explained why you set up the box, she knows what you were hoping to create. She doesn't have to share that goal, but you don't have to keep supplying a project that no longer feels worthwhile to you.

A take-one limit might preserve the part you enjoyed without a complicated list of approved uses. It wouldn't require you to decide whether each person's reason for wanting a book was good enough.

It might, but the narrator doesn't want to monitor quantities either. A sign could be worth one try if they're interested. It shouldn't become another job they're obliged to take on before they're allowed to stop.

Join the discussion

More in AITA