Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for changing our family holiday dinner from served plates to a buffet?

AITA category photographAITA

My mother looked at the serving dishes on the counter and said, “So we're all lining up with our plates now?”

This is the first year I've hosted our family holiday dinner. At her house, she and my aunt used to plate every meal in the kitchen and carry it out. I always liked how special that felt. I didn't appreciate how much of the evening they spent serving until I started planning it myself.

A week beforehand I told the family I would cook the meal but set it out so everyone could help themselves. My mother offered to come early and plate it with me. I declined because I wanted her sitting down too, and because I didn't want to coordinate twelve individual plates.

At dinner she offered again. I said, in front of everyone, “If I have to run a restaurant, we can book one next year.” She went quiet and later said I'd made a tradition she worked hard on sound ridiculous. She wasn't demanding that I do it alone; she had offered help.

I enjoyed actually sitting with people. I also realize my comment landed on the person who gave me all those lovely dinners. AITA for refusing her help and changing how the meal was served?

Discussion

5 community replies

The buffet was a reasonable hosting choice. The restaurant comment was the part I'd repair. She had offered to share the work, so it answered her generosity as though she'd handed you a list of demands.

You can love the dinners your mother made and still serve yours from the counter. Tell her both.

You gave notice a week ahead. She could be disappointed, but asking again at dinner put you in the position of defending a decision you'd already explained. That context matters even though your reply was sharp.

Could you keep one small ceremonial part, like bringing the main dish to the table together? It might preserve what she values without making you carry twelve completed plates.

That could work if the narrator likes it too. I'd first ask which part her mother actually misses. It might be the shared kitchen time with the aunt, rather than anything about how the plates reach the table.

Join the discussion

More in AITA