Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for being disappointed that my birthday present was a laundry hamper?

AITA category photographAITA

I opened the big box expecting something personal. It was the laundry hamper I'd pointed out to my partner a few weeks earlier because ours was cracked.

He remembered the exact one, ordered it, and wrapped it. He also made breakfast and bought a card with a lovely message. I know there was thought involved. Still, my first response was, “Oh. For the house?”

We share the laundry, and the hamper is for our bedroom. I hadn't said I wanted it as a gift; I'd said we needed to replace ours. We normally buy each other modest presents connected to hobbies or things the person enjoys. Money wasn't so tight that this had to replace both a household purchase and my birthday present.

He says I mentioned wanting it, he listened, and now I'm upset because he didn't read my mind about what counts as romantic. I said I wouldn't give him replacement bin bags for his birthday. That comparison hurt him because he'd chosen something nicer and expected me to be pleased.

I thanked him for the breakfast and card. I haven't asked him to buy another present. AITA for saying the hamper didn't feel like a gift for me?

Discussion

5 community replies

NAH about the initial mismatch. He remembered a real preference, and you wanted something chosen for your birthday rather than a shared chore. Those can both be true. The bin-bag comparison made his attempt sound more careless than the details suggest.

A replacement for a shared broken hamper is easy to hear as a household purchase. Your disappointment isn't mysterious.

Next year, distinguish things you like from things you'd like as presents. For now, you could say: “I appreciated you remembering the exact one. I wanted a birthday gift connected to something I enjoy.” He may still be hurt, but that's a more useful explanation than comparing his choice to bin bags.

The breakfast and card are doing a lot of work here. If you describe the whole birthday as thoughtless because the boxed present disappointed you, I think that's unfair to him.

Agreed, and the post says the narrator thanked him for those parts. A useful conversation should preserve that appreciation while still making room for the one disappointment. Otherwise neither of them learns much for next year.

Join the discussion

More in AITA