Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for backing out of our siblings' joint gift after finding my own present?

AITA category photographAITA

I told my siblings I'd found a better idea for Mum and wanted to leave the joint gift. They said they'd already ordered it on the understanding that all three of us were paying.

We'd agreed on a weekend art course she'd mentioned. I said yes to my share. Then I found an old family photograph and arranged to have it restored and framed. I thought it would mean more coming from me than adding my name to a course booking.

My siblings aren't objecting to the photograph. They say buying it doesn't undo the first agreement or reduce the bill they've committed to. I said Mum didn't need me paying for two birthday gifts.

They replied that nobody had asked me to buy the second one. I can afford my original share, but paying it would make my thoughtful idea feel like an expensive detour instead of the gift I chose.

AITA for asking them to cover the course between themselves?

Discussion

5 community replies

YTA. You agreed to the course before they ordered it. Finding a present you prefer doesn't move your agreed share onto the other two people.

The framed photograph can still be your personal gesture. Paying what you promised doesn't make it less thoughtful; it makes it an additional choice you made after a shared commitment.

You could ask whether the booking can be changed, without assuming that it can. But don't make your siblings responsible for fixing the budget because the second idea felt more meaningful to you.

Tell them you understand why they relied on your yes. That matters more than persuading them which gift Mum will enjoy most.

Exactly. Even if the photograph becomes her favourite present, it won't retroactively make the course agreement disappear. Gift quality and keeping the payment promise are separate questions.

Join the discussion

More in AITA