Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for backing out of cooking night over my roommate's smoke-alarm plan?

AITA category photographAITA

While we were unpacking groceries for a cooking night, my roommate said he'd take the battery out of the smoke alarm before everyone arrived. He said it had interrupted his cooking before and he'd put it back after dinner.

I told him I wouldn't cook or co-host with the alarm disabled. We live in the US, and I sent him the U.S. Fire Administration's guidance, which specifically advises against removing a smoke-alarm battery while cooking. Nothing was cooking and no alarm was sounding during this argument.

He said I was acting as if he couldn't be trusted to stand beside a pan. I said, “Then you'll need someone else to help you tonight.” I left my share of the ingredients with him and went to my room. I haven't cancelled anything or contacted our guests. He hasn't agreed to keep the battery in.

We planned this together, and he'd done most of the shopping while I was supposed to do the prep and help people cook. He says raising a concern was fine, but withdrawing my help left all the work with him. AITA for making my participation conditional this late?

Discussion

5 community replies

NTA for refusing to cook with the alarm disabled. Standing beside the pan doesn't answer your objection. You raised a specific condition he can still meet before anyone arrives.

Going to your room leaves a practical conversation unfinished. Tell him whether you're ready to do the prep if he keeps the alarm powered. Otherwise he may spend the afternoon planning around your absence while you assume the offer is still obvious.

You can acknowledge his shopping work without treating it as a debt that requires you to accept his plan. Offer to help choose a different menu or contact guests together if the two of you can't agree on how to host.

I'd avoid turning this into a trial of whether he's a trustworthy person. Keep it concrete: you'll do your agreed share with the alarm operating, and you won't do it with the battery removed. He can disagree with your tone without getting a different answer on that condition.

That framing also gives him a way to change his mind without first admitting he's a terrible host. If he drops the battery plan, take yes for an answer and get on with the prep. The point is to have the protection working, not to win a confession.

Join the discussion

More in AITA