Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for asking our group to vote again because I disliked the restaurant that won?

AITA category photographAITA

I suggested a vote to choose our next group dinner. When the noodle place won, I asked whether we could narrow it to the other two options and vote again.

Nobody had a dietary restriction or a price problem with the winner. I just don't like it much. My preferred place came second. I'd included all three in the poll because people had suggested them, and I hadn't said I would reject any result.

A friend replied, “So we vote until your choice wins?” I said a dinner should be something everyone enjoys, not something imposed by a small majority. She pointed out that I'd proposed the vote and only started talking about full agreement after losing it.

I said I'd still go if everyone insisted. That apparently sounded like another attempt to make people feel bad about choosing it. I do want to see them, and the food isn't so bad that I'd refuse to eat there.

AITA for asking for another vote rather than quietly accepting a plan I wasn't excited about?

Discussion

5 community replies

YTA. You proposed the process, listed the options, and tried to change it once you saw the answer. Your friend's summary is pretty accurate.

You could say, “I realize I shouldn't have included a place I didn't want. Let's keep the result, and I'll suggest something different next time.” That owns the mistake without making dinner a test of whether everyone cares about your preferences.

Consensus is a reasonable way to plan a meal too. It needs to be the method you agree on before the vote, rather than a new requirement that appears when the vote disappoints you.

I don't think voting should mean someone can never raise a concern afterward. Sometimes seeing a result makes people realize what they actually want.

Raising the concern was allowed; the group heard it. But there's no new restriction or practical problem here, just a preference already represented in the original vote. They can reasonably keep the result.

Join the discussion

More in AITA