Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for asking my sister to leave my child out of her public family-photo challenge?

AITA category photographAITA

My sister sent me a preview of her week of family photographs. My son was in several, and I asked her to replace those before posting them publicly.

She says I post pictures of him myself, so she doesn't understand why the same kind of image is different on her account. We'd previously agreed she'd ask before sharing pictures of him. She thought that meant only checking whether the photograph was unflattering.

I meant checking whether I was comfortable with the particular post at all. I share occasional pictures on my own account; I don't want that to become an ongoing family project I haven't agreed to.

She'd spent time arranging the sequence and says removing him makes the week look less like our actual family life. I said the project could still represent her week without including every person who was there.

AITA for drawing a distinction she thinks is inconsistent with my own posts?

Discussion

5 community replies

NTA. Posting a picture yourself doesn't mean you've agreed to every future post by somebody else. The point of asking first was that a particular use could get a no.

The two of you understood the earlier agreement differently. Say explicitly that checking means you may decline the post, not just request a more flattering photograph. That avoids the same confusion next time.

She can be disappointed about changing the sequence. Don't dismiss the work, but don't let the amount of editing become the reason you must approve the images.

Ask her to show you the revised selection if you want to resolve the immediate issue. Keep the request focused on replacing the pictures rather than debating whether she is allowed to remember the week as family time.

Right. You aren't editing her memories by asking for a different public selection. She can keep the private photographs and still choose what to post with the agreement you've clarified.

Join the discussion

More in AITA