Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for asking my roommate to replace a whole sketchpad after she used five sheets?

AITA category photographAITA

My roommate wrote shopping lists on five sheets from my drawing pad. I asked her to replace the pad.

I'd previously told her she could use pens and paper from my desk drawer. The pad was in that drawer, with ordinary printer paper underneath it. I meant spare writing paper, but hadn't said that or marked the drawing pad as separate.

She apologized and offered to pay for the five sheets. I said I wanted an intact pad for my work, not a partly used one. She says the pad still has plenty left and replacing all of it is a disproportionate bill for following permission I gave her.

I can move the drawing supplies elsewhere now. AITA for wanting a new pad rather than just the cost of what she used?

Discussion

5 community replies

YTA for treating the whole-pad replacement as something she obviously owes. You gave broad permission and kept both kinds of paper together.

You can explain why the drawing paper matters to you without turning the explanation into proof that she should have known. It wasn't labeled, and she offered to cover what she used.

What about accepting her offer for the sheets and keeping the pad for work that doesn't need the full number? If you personally want a completely new one, that preference needn't become her whole expense.

Some people plan a project around a complete sketchbook. If the missing sheets disrupt that, a new pad might be more reasonable than dividing its price by the page count.

Possibly, but the post doesn't describe such a project. I'd want that explanation before treating an intact pad as essential. The broad permission would still matter when deciding how to share the cost.

Join the discussion

More in AITA