Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for asking my partner not to join my monthly breakfast with an old friend?

AITA category photographAITA

"What time are we meeting Sam?" my partner asked.

I said this month's breakfast was going to be just me and Sam. My partner looked hurt. He'd joined the previous one because Sam wanted to meet him, and he thought it had become something we did together.

Sam and I have had occasional one-to-one breakfasts since school. I like the space to catch up without explaining every old reference or balancing a three-person conversation. My partner has been part of other outings with Sam and our wider friends.

I told him that I wanted to keep this particular meeting as friend time. He said he hadn't realized meeting an important person in my life came with a limit on being included again. I replied, "You don't have to be everywhere I am," which made the discussion much more defensive.

I'm not hiding the friendship or asking my partner to avoid Sam. I want a recurring part of my life to stay one-to-one even as our lives become more connected.

AITA for withdrawing what he thought was an invitation, rather than letting him come and clarifying it afterward?

Discussion

5 community replies

The previous invitation was to meet Sam, not necessarily to join every later breakfast. It's reasonable to keep some one-to-one friendships alongside a relationship. Your partner can still have misunderstood the scope in good faith.

The 'everywhere I am' line made one assumed invitation sound like evidence that he was generally intrusive. If this was the first disagreement of that kind, acknowledge that you made it broader than the facts.

Be specific about including him in other settings because that is already part of the friendship you describe. You don't have to offer every breakfast to demonstrate that Sam and your partner are welcome in the same room.

If this is your preference, own it as yours. Don't present Sam as the reason unless Sam has actually said they want the same arrangement. That would put an absent friend into an argument they didn't choose.

Agreed. 'I value this time with my old friend' is a clearer explanation than making either Sam or the partner responsible for the boundary. Another shared outing can be offered because you want it, not as a fee for keeping this breakfast one-to-one.

Join the discussion

More in AITA