Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for asking my friend to turn his speaker off during our nature walk?

AITA category photographAITA

My friend brought a small speaker on a group nature walk and started playing a playlist he'd made for us. After a few songs, I asked him to switch it off.

He offered to lower the volume. I said I'd rather hear the place we had come to walk in. He turned it off, but asked why my idea of a nice walk should count more than his. Two other people shrugged and said they didn't mind either way.

We hadn't agreed on music beforehand. The speaker wasn't blaring, although I could hear it several paces away, and other walkers passed us. He said he'd spent time choosing songs and thought it would make the outing more fun. I said a shared path wasn't a place where our group got to decide the soundtrack. He called that a lecture.

I've since read the National Park Service's hiking etiquette guidance, which recommends limiting noise from electronic devices. I don't know of a specific speaker rule for the path we used, and I wasn't claiming he had broken one.

AITA for asking for no music instead of accepting his offer to turn it down?

Discussion

5 community replies

NTA for asking. Lower volume would still mean listening to a playlist you didn't choose, on an outing where music wasn't part of the plan. He complied, so I'd also acknowledge that rather than treating the disagreement as ongoing defiance.

He was trying to contribute something thoughtful. You can appreciate the playlist and suggest using it during a meal together another time. That gives the effort somewhere to go without promising to like it on a walk.

Other people passed you on the path. Even unanimous enthusiasm within your group wouldn't tell you what those walkers wanted to hear.

I'd have tried the lower volume first. A request for total silence can feel like one person's preference becoming the rule, especially when the others in the group aren't bothered.

The request was for the speaker to be off, not for everyone to stop talking. And the others' indifference doesn't cancel the one person who did mind. He could reasonably be disappointed about the playlist without needing it to play throughout the walk.

Join the discussion

More in AITA