Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for asking my friend to stop saying “I told you so” while helping fix my knitting?

AITA category photographAITA

On the third “I did tell you,” I put down my knitting and asked my friend whether we could just fix the jumper.

She had told me to check the fit before carrying on. I didn't. I wanted to finish, and by the time I tried it on, I'd made far more than I wanted to redo. I asked if she'd sit with me while I worked out what to undo. She agreed and came over.

The first joke was fair. I laughed. By the third, I said I knew I'd ignored her and that hearing it again wasn't helping. She said I wanted the benefit of her advice without admitting she was right. I said I'd already admitted it when I asked for help.

She packed up and left. Now I have a half-undone jumper and a message saying I can figure it out myself if her company is so irritating.

I don't think she owes me an evening of help. I also didn't think accepting the help meant I had to keep laughing at the same mistake. AITA for asking her to stop when she was doing me a favour?

Discussion

5 community replies

A favour doesn't buy unlimited repetitions of the joke. You acknowledged the advice, laughed once and then asked to move on. That sounds reasonable, provided the request wasn't delivered as though she were an employee failing to get on with the repair.

“Could we just fix the jumper?” could sound dismissive after she'd given up her evening. If that was your tone, apologise for it and thank her for coming. That wouldn't mean accepting a running commentary.

She may have been frustrated that advice you ignored had become a bigger request for her time. That doesn't make the repeated digs useful, but it's worth acknowledging the extra work when you speak again.

The practical limit is that she's allowed to stop helping. You can ask for less teasing; you can't require her to continue the evening on those terms. Take some time before asking her for another repair session.

True, but her freedom to leave doesn't make your request rude by itself. Both people can decline an arrangement they don't enjoy. Repairing the friendship may mean talking about the favour and the jokes, then finishing the jumper another way.

Join the discussion

More in AITA