Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for asking my brother to write down a repayment plan before I lend him money?

AITA category photographAITA

"You lent me forty dollars without making a document," my brother said when I sent him the repayment questions.

This time he wanted $900 toward replacing his stolen bicycle. He uses it to get to work. I said I could consider lending the money, but wanted us to agree when repayments would start, what he could realistically send and what we'd do if that changed.

He said he would pay me back as soon as he could. I asked what that meant in practice. He replied that family should be able to help without making someone feel like a risky application.

I found the CFPB's guidance on family lending useful because it recommends discussing expectations and writing down what everyone agrees. I sent him the link, which he found more impersonal than reassuring.

He has repaid small amounts promptly before. I'm not trying to accuse him of planning otherwise. But $900 is money I'd need back, and I don't want an undefined promise to become a recurring argument.

No money has changed hands. AITA for making the written plan a condition rather than simply trusting him?

Discussion

5 community replies

The CFPB's guidance encourages agreeing on what is being provided, repayment expectations and what happens if circumstances change, with a written record if possible. That supports a conversation about clarity. It doesn't make any plan a guarantee that money will be repaid.

His record with small amounts deserves acknowledgment. Asking about $900 needn't mean you believe the earlier repayments were meaningless. Say both things plainly rather than letting the questions carry your whole attitude toward him.

'As soon as I can' may be sincere and still leave you imagining different dates. If you need the money back, it's better to discover that mismatch before sending it than after either person has relied on an assumption.

The link may have felt like being referred to a policy desk when he wanted to hear his sibling. Could you work through the questions together in ordinary language instead of asking him to respond to a document alone?

That would make the process warmer without removing the condition. The brother also needs room to say the arrangement doesn't work for him. The point is an agreement both can understand, not getting a signature as proof of affection.

Join the discussion

More in AITA