AITA for asking my brother to replace my bicycle helmet after he crashed in it?
AITAMy brother returned my bicycle helmet and said it had “only picked up a scratch.” Then he explained that he'd fallen while riding and the helmet had hit the pavement while he was wearing it.
I'd lent it to him for a weekend visit. It was only a few months old. I told him I wouldn't keep using it after that impact and asked him to cover an equivalent replacement. He offered half, saying I'd agreed to lend it and accidents were part of borrowing things.
I sent him Health Canada's helmet guidance, which says single-impact helmets, including bicycle helmets, must be replaced after an impact even without visible damage. He says he accepts that I want a new one but thinks I'm applying a worst-case rule to make him pay.
I had mentioned wanting a more expensive helmet in a different colour before the visit. I'm not asking him to fund that upgrade; I said I'd cover any difference myself. He still thinks the accident has conveniently brought forward a purchase I was already considering.
AITA for asking for the whole cost of an equivalent replacement when he didn't damage it deliberately?