Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for asking my brother to replace my bicycle helmet after he crashed in it?

AITA category photographAITA

My brother returned my bicycle helmet and said it had “only picked up a scratch.” Then he explained that he'd fallen while riding and the helmet had hit the pavement while he was wearing it.

I'd lent it to him for a weekend visit. It was only a few months old. I told him I wouldn't keep using it after that impact and asked him to cover an equivalent replacement. He offered half, saying I'd agreed to lend it and accidents were part of borrowing things.

I sent him Health Canada's helmet guidance, which says single-impact helmets, including bicycle helmets, must be replaced after an impact even without visible damage. He says he accepts that I want a new one but thinks I'm applying a worst-case rule to make him pay.

I had mentioned wanting a more expensive helmet in a different colour before the visit. I'm not asking him to fund that upgrade; I said I'd cover any difference myself. He still thinks the accident has conveniently brought forward a purchase I was already considering.

AITA for asking for the whole cost of an equivalent replacement when he didn't damage it deliberately?

Discussion

5 community replies

The replacement isn't just a preference for a nicer colour. The impact changed whether you can keep relying on this helmet, even if the mark looks minor. His lack of intent matters to how you speak to him; it doesn't make the equipment unchanged.

An equivalent replacement, with you paying for any upgrade, sounds fair to me. Show him the two choices separately so this doesn't remain an argument about whether you've found a way to get the expensive one.

You can be glad he told you about the impact and still ask him to replace the helmet. Don't make honesty about a borrowing accident feel like the mistake; you needed that information before using it again.

I wouldn't use the safety guidance as if it also sets the financial settlement. It explains why the helmet needs replacing. Whether he covers all of an equivalent new one is still the family fairness question you're discussing.

Agreed. Keeping those separate may help him stop treating payment as a vote on whether the helmet is safe. Even if the two of you disagree about cost, the impact guidance doesn't change.

Join the discussion

More in AITA