Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for asking a guest to show why he needed his phone at our phone-free dinner?

AITA category photographAITA

A guest said his phone was connected to his glucose monitor. I said he could keep it, but asked him to show me the screen so the others would know I wasn't making an exception for a friend.

I'd invited everyone to put their phones in a basket during dinner. He was a friend of my partner's, and I hadn't met him before. He explained quietly why he needed his beside him. I didn't take it or ask him to switch it off.

He declined to show me anything and said his explanation should have been enough. My partner told me to leave it. I did, but afterwards said I was trying to make the rule fair rather than single him out.

My partner says I did single him out by turning a health-related explanation into something he had to demonstrate to the table. Nobody else had asked why he still had his phone.

AITA for asking for confirmation instead of accepting an exception I couldn't check?

Discussion

5 community replies

A phone can be part of glucose monitoring: NIDDK explains that CGM information may be sent to an app on a smartphone. You didn't need access to his readings to accept what he told you about his own setup.

YTA. Fairness didn't require him to display health information so you could justify your hosting decision. The other guests weren't even asking for an explanation; you created an audience for a concern you had.

The quiet explanation gave you an easy way to keep things ordinary. A simple “of course” would have let him keep the phone without making his reason part of dinner conversation.

For another phone-free evening, make room for guests who need a device without asking them to apply publicly for an exemption. You can ask for attention at dinner while accepting that phones have uses beyond messages and scrolling.

Yes, and if someone privately gives you a reason, don't repeat it to make the exception look deserved. You can handle questions about your own house rule without making that guest supply the defence.

Join the discussion

More in AITA