Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

A phone app named the mushrooms my brother found. How do I stop that becoming permission to cook them?

Family category photographFamily

My brother sent a photograph of wild mushrooms and the name suggested by an image-recognition app. He's new to foraging and wants to cook them during our family weekend. I replied, 'Soup sorted,' before thinking about what we'd actually established.

No one has eaten them. Poison Control advises never eating a wild mushroom unless a mushroom-identification expert has confirmed it. A name from the app isn't the expert confirmation we need.

How do I withdraw my enthusiastic answer without making the weekend an argument about whether my brother is clever enough to recognise things? The children are now excited about collecting food on the walk, and I don't want that excitement to become a reason to guess.

Discussion

5 community replies

Correct the soup comment before the weekend. You were joining in the excitement, but you hadn't established that the mushrooms were suitable to eat. Don't leave the children expecting a taste while the adults debate it.

The Poison Control warning is about expert identification, not how confident someone feels about a suggested name. Trying another identification guess or tasting a little isn't the missing confirmation.

Discuss the plan with your brother privately first, then give the children a clear shared answer. They shouldn't have to decide which adult's confidence sounds most convincing.

Could the walk remain about noticing and photographing things rather than promising ingredients for dinner?

Yes. Ask what the children are curious about and plan an activity that doesn't depend on eating a find. Learning about mushrooms can continue without this collection becoming food, and dinner can be arranged separately without treating that change as a defeat.

Join the discussion

More in Family