Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Would changing the number of US Supreme Court justices require a constitutional amendment?

Politics category photographPolitics

At our politics reading group, someone dismissed a discussion about the size of the US Supreme Court by saying, 'Nine is in the Constitution, so there's nothing Congress could do without an amendment.' I nearly repeated that in our meeting notes because nine feels like such a fixed part of the institution.

The Court's own general FAQ says Congress determines the number and describes earlier changes made by legislation. So the number of seats is not itself fixed at nine by the Constitution.

I'm comfortable correcting that narrow factual point. I'm less comfortable turning it into 'changing the Court would be straightforward', which sounds like a judgement about political feasibility and institutional consequences. How should the notes acknowledge the route without making the correction read as an argument for changing the Court?

Discussion

5 community replies

'Congress determines the number of justices; nine is not constitutionally fixed' corrects the claim without recommending a change.

The practical difficulty matters, but it answers a different question. Something can be available through legislation and still face strong opposition. Keep that uncertainty attached to any claim about what could actually happen.

I'd correct the notes even if everyone present opposed expansion. Leaving a mistaken procedural claim in place because it supports the group's preferred conclusion would make the notes less useful.

I would record the trust concern as well. A correction that only says Congress can change the number could make the group sound more comfortable with change than it was.

Yes, if that concern was actually expressed: attribute it as a view raised in the discussion. Put it beside the accurate explanation of who sets the number, rather than using it to preserve the mistaken claim about the Constitution.

Join the discussion

More in Politics