Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Who appoints the UN Secretary-General: the General Assembly or the Security Council?

Politics category photographPolitics

A friend described the UN Secretary-General as someone 'elected by the whole world'. When I questioned that, another person said the Security Council simply chooses the Secretary-General and the General Assembly has no role. I want a short explanation for our discussion notes that doesn't replace one misleading shortcut with another.

The UN library's explanation points to Article 97 of the Charter: the General Assembly appoints the Secretary-General on the Security Council's recommendation. That gives both bodies a role; it isn't a worldwide public ballot.

We're discussing the institution, rather than predicting any current appointment. Would 'appointed by the General Assembly following a Security Council recommendation' be enough? I don't want the description to imply either a direct popular mandate or that the Assembly is absent from the process.

Discussion

5 community replies

Keep that sentence. It names who recommends and who appoints, without inventing a public election.

'The whole world elects them' could be intended as shorthand for an international process. Even so, it leaves a reader with the wrong picture of who is actually taking part.

I'd resist replacing 'appoints' with 'rubber-stamps' in the factual notes. That word adds a judgement about the Assembly's role. If someone wants to argue about how much influence it has, let them make that argument separately.

Could the notes just say 'chosen by the UN'? The full institutional wording feels heavy for a casual discussion.

It depends on why the sentence is there. If the question is precisely which UN body does what, 'chosen by the UN' hides the answer. The two-stage wording is short enough to keep, with the rest of the procedural detail left out.

Join the discussion

More in Politics