Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Relationships · Advice & Questions ·

When I say I'm hurt, my friend calls herself terrible and I end up comforting her

Relationships category photographRelationships

I told a close friend I was disappointed she'd forgotten a plan we'd made. She said, "I'm such a terrible friend. You'd be better off without me." I immediately said that wasn't true and listed the things I love about her.

By the end of the call, she'd stopped crying, but we hadn't talked about the afternoon I'd kept free. This has happened a few times. I don't think she's performing the distress; she sounds genuinely upset. I still leave feeling that bringing up a small hurt has created a much bigger job.

I want to be kind without having to withdraw what I said. How do I stay with the original issue when reassuring her becomes the whole conversation?

Discussion

5 community replies

"I care about you, and I don't think you're a terrible friend. I'm talking about this one plan." You can offer that reassurance without listing evidence until your own disappointment disappears. The friendship doesn't have to be put on trial for you to discuss an afternoon.

There is a difference between retracting "you're terrible," which you never said, and retracting "I was disappointed," which you did mean. It may help to say that distinction aloud if she hears every complaint as a verdict on the friendship.

Bring up the pattern at a calm time too. You can describe what happens without claiming to know why: "When I mention being hurt, we end up discussing whether you're a good friend, and the original thing stays unresolved." Her distress may be sincere and the pattern may still be difficult for you.

If she is too upset to continue, you could pause the conversation and name when you'd like to return to it. A pause doesn't need to mean pretending the plan no longer matters. Nor do you need to keep talking until she agrees with you.

A return time makes that pause different from quietly abandoning the subject. Something like "Let's leave this for tonight and talk tomorrow about how we make plans" gives both people a chance to come back without staging the whole call again.

Join the discussion

More in Relationships