Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Relationships · Advice & Questions ·

My brother says a rental guarantee is just a reference. How do I slow this down?

Relationships category photographRelationships

My brother is applying for a flat in England and has asked me to be his guarantor. He described it as "basically a reference from someone with a steady job." I said I would look at the paperwork. He has since told our parents that I am doing it and asked me to sign as soon as the agent sends it over.

I haven't seen the tenancy or guarantee and haven't signed anything. When I said I wanted to understand the commitment first, he heard that as doubt about whether he pays his bills. He has paid back money he borrowed from me before, but I don't think that answers what this document would ask of me.

I want him to get the flat. I also want to be able to decide against signing without the whole family treating it as a verdict on his character. How can I put the decision back on those terms?

Discussion

5 community replies

Correct the announcement now: "I agreed to read the documents, not to be your guarantor. Please tell Mum and Dad that I haven't decided." Waiting until the paperwork arrives gives the family more time to treat your decision as settled and makes your eventual answer harder to hear.

This needs more than a good opinion of your brother. Shelter's guidance for England explains that a guarantor can be responsible for unpaid rent and, depending on the agreement, other costs or joint tenants' rent. Read both the tenancy and guarantee; get independent housing or legal advice about the actual terms before deciding. This thread cannot establish your liability.

Don't try to win the argument by producing a list of his past mistakes. You could trust him to intend to pay and still decline a financial commitment you don't want. Keeping those ideas separate may protect more of the relationship than arguing about whether he is reliable enough.

If you decide no, be careful with "I wish I could" if what you mean is "I have decided I won't." The first wording invites people to solve your supposed obstacle. You can be sympathetic about the housing pressure and still give an answer that doesn't require their agreement.

You can also offer something smaller, such as helping him organise applications, if you actually want to. But name that as a separate offer. He should not have to interpret a vague promise of help as another possible guarantee, and you shouldn't offer a substitute commitment just to make your refusal sound nicer.

Join the discussion

More in Relationships