What is a fair way to buy out a neighbour's share of a gazebo when she moves away?
Neighbours“I put in fifty pounds, so fifty pounds back seems straightforward,” my neighbour said.
Four households each paid £50 for a gazebo two years ago. We agreed it was a joint purchase for our gatherings, but never discussed someone leaving. It has been used often and now has a patched section.
She is moving and wants the other three households to buy her share. They think the current condition should affect the amount. Nobody has checked what a comparable used gazebo would cost, and we haven't agreed that keeping it is the only option.
She also stored it most of the time. I am grateful for that work, though I don't want us to invent a storage bill now because discussing the purchase price feels uncomfortable.
Should we agree a current value, offer the original contribution as goodwill, or consider selling it and dividing the proceeds by agreement? I want a fair conversation before the move turns our missing exit plan into a personal dispute.