Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

My neighbour makes a story about me funnier by changing what I said

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

I once mistook a neighbour's umbrella stand for something that was going out with the rubbish and asked whether it was free. He said no; I laughed, apologised and left it where it was.

He now tells the story as though I tried to carry it home and argued when he stopped me. The first time he told that version, I laughed because everyone else did. Last night I said I hadn't picked it up, and he replied, “Don't ruin a good story.”

I can laugh at my original mistake. I don't like being the person who argued for someone else's belongings. How do I ask him to keep the funny part without the extra behaviour?

Discussion

5 community replies

The distinction is quite specific: asking whether something is free isn't trying to take it after being told no. Tell him that privately, and ask him to leave the invented argument out.

Laughing the first time may explain why he thought the version had landed well. You can acknowledge that without treating it as permission for every retelling.

The umbrella stand mistake already has a joke in it. He doesn't need you to become more unreasonable each time for the original misunderstanding to be worth telling.

You could correct the factual bit lightly when it comes up: “I asked; I didn't attempt an umbrella-stand heist.” That might keep the room relaxed while giving people the right version.

That works only if you're comfortable making another joke. You can also say plainly that you didn't pick it up or argue. Being accurate shouldn't depend on producing a better punchline than his.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours