Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Funny · Advice & Questions ·

What do I say after guessing a much grander present than my friend bought?

Funny category photographFunny

'A telescope?' I said, with far too much excitement for an unopened box.

My friend had asked me to guess my birthday present. The box was long, and she knows I like looking at the night sky. My imagination had built an observatory before I'd removed the paper.

It was an umbrella with a pattern of little planets. I liked it. She said, 'Oh, not quite that exciting,' and I felt I'd made a thoughtful present arrive as a disappointment.

What do I say now without producing a suspicious speech about how umbrellas are everything I've ever wanted? I would like her actual gift to get a turn after my imaginary one.

Discussion

5 community replies

You can acknowledge the leap: 'I got carried away guessing. This is lovely; you remembered the sort of pattern I like.' Keep the appreciation tied to something true about the umbrella.

Being asked to guess wasn't a promise that you'd name the right object. The awkward part is the comparison left hanging, and you can move away from that without apologising for having an imagination.

Don't claim you never wanted a telescope if you clearly sounded delighted by the idea. You can have a bigger wish and still appreciate what your friend chose for you.

A grand repair performance could leave her reassuring you about the guess instead of enjoying giving the present. One warm, specific response gives her less to manage than a prolonged account of your guilt.

Let the umbrella have an ordinary life after that. You don't need to send proof of every use to show she has finally overcome the telescope.

Join the discussion

More in Funny