Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

What do I do when two neighbours win a free quiz and I have only one prize?

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

Two answer sheets were completely correct, and both arrived before the stated closing time. I had bought one book token.

I ran a free quiz at our neighbours' afternoon gathering. The invitation promised a prize for the winner but said nothing about a tie. One entrant handed her sheet in earlier; the other says there was only a closing time, not a race.

A helper wants to use the submission order because it gives us an answer quickly. I am uncomfortable introducing a rule after seeing who it would favour. I could buy another small prize, though that is more than I budgeted.

Should I explain the omission and ask both winners about an agreed way forward? I want to recognise their results without pretending I announced a tie-breaker that I only thought of afterwards.

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell them both they answered everything correctly and that you hadn't provided a tie rule. Acknowledging the missing arrangement is a better start than presenting the helper's suggestion as something already settled.

If you can comfortably provide a second prize, that is one straightforward option. It can be a goodwill decision about this event rather than an expectation that you will cover every future omission.

Earlier submission would have been a possible rule to announce in advance. It wasn't the one participants were given, so ask before using it to settle this result.

Could they agree to share the value of the token? That might avoid both an extra purchase and choosing one winner.

You can offer that possibility if it is practical for the actual prize, but don't assume a token can be divided or that both people want to share it. Ask them about workable options without making their agreement a test of generosity.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours