Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Funny · Advice & Questions ·

What do I do after asking a friend to judge the present I'd already chosen for her?

Funny category photographFunny

'Would you want a goose-shaped vase?' I asked. My friend said, 'Absolutely not,' with admirable clarity.

I had already chosen one for her birthday. I thought the question would confirm how well I knew her and let me enjoy the secret for another week. Instead I nodded thoughtfully while a wrapped goose waited at home.

She doesn't know why I asked. Part of me wants to explain, so she'll see that the question wasn't random. Another part recognises that this would make her manage my disappointment in a present she hasn't received.

What do I do with the information she gave me? I would rather adjust my plan than arrange a ceremony in which she has to reverse her opinion of a goose.

Discussion

5 community replies

Treat her answer as useful information and choose a different plan if you can. You asked for a preference; you don't need to reveal the wrapped vase merely to make the answer more comfortable for you.

A secret check isn't very informative if the only acceptable answer is approval. This one did tell you something, even though it wasn't what you hoped to hear.

Did she say what sort of thing she would enjoy instead? If she did, use that. If she didn't, you can make a simpler choice without turning the next conversation into another concealed test.

You may still like the goose and feel disappointed about not giving it. That feeling doesn't require her to explain why she dislikes it or reassure you that she would have loved yours.

The goose can have an uncertain future without becoming her responsibility. You can appreciate the thought you put in and still decide that her answer changes what you give her.

Join the discussion

More in Funny