Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Relationships · Advice & Questions ·

What can I say when a grieving friend doesn't want comforting stories about her mother?

Relationships category photographRelationships

When my friend's mother died, I said, "At least you know how much she loved you." My friend replied, "Please don't make her into someone she wasn't."

I knew their relationship had been painful. I also remember her mother being kind to me, and I reached for the sort of reassurance I thought people said after a death. My friend told me she was sad, angry and tired of everyone choosing the nicest version of her mum.

I want to apologise and be someone she can talk to. I'm worried I'll either keep trying to make it better or sound as though I am agreeing with a judgment about her whole family. What does useful company look like here?

Discussion

5 community replies

"I'm sorry. I spoke as though I knew what your relationship meant, and I didn't listen to what you've told me. You don't need to make it sound nicer for me." That apology addresses the sentence that hurt her without asking her to reassure you about your intentions.

NHS guidance on bereavement describes anger and guilt among possible grief responses and says people experience loss differently. Don't use that as a label for her, though. It is a reason to leave room for the feelings she is actually describing.

You could ask whether she wants to talk, have help with a particular errand, or just spend an ordinary afternoon together. Let her answer for today. Offering company doesn't require you to find a sentence that makes the death or the relationship feel better.

Your own memories can be true without answering hers. If she says her mother hurt her, "but she was kind to me" changes whose experience you are discussing. You can keep your memory without producing it as a correction.

That distinction should ease the fear about endorsing a judgment on the whole family. Listening to what happened to your friend doesn't require delivering your own final verdict on her mother. You can respond to the experience she has trusted you with.

Join the discussion

More in Relationships