Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

We still have a quorum, but several members left before the vote. Should we carry on?

Politics category photographPolitics

Our civic association meeting ran late, and several members left for commitments they had warned us about. The vote on next season's meeting venue is still waiting. Enough people remain for a quorum under our rules, which allow them to take the decision.

The chair wants to finish because the venue's booking window closes before our next ordinary meeting. Another member wants a fresh meeting with a clear voting time, even if that means losing the offer. Nobody deliberately moved the item, but we knew some people couldn't stay late and still let earlier discussion overrun.

Would you carry on, postpone, or look for another route permitted by the rules? I don't want departures to become a way to stop every decision, but being technically able to vote doesn't answer whether we gave members a fair chance to take part.

Discussion

5 community replies

The warning about when people had to leave matters. I'd ask whether there is a permitted way to reconvene soon enough, rather than assuming the only alternatives are voting now or waiting for the next ordinary meeting.

What were members told about the likely timing of this item? If the agenda gave them a reasonable expectation of being there for it, that should be part of the decision now.

People who stayed have costs too. They shouldn't repeatedly have to attend another meeting because earlier items overrun. Whatever happens with this vote, the chair needs a more realistic way to manage the next agenda.

I'd usually finish a decision when the meeting is still quorate. Otherwise leaving early could give someone a veto they wouldn't have had in the vote.

That is a real concern, but it doesn't make every delay the same. Here the departures were announced and the meeting overran. I'd weigh that alongside the booking deadline, and explain the choice without guessing how the absent members would have voted.

Join the discussion

More in Politics