Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Career / Work · Advice & Questions ·

We resolved the complaint. My manager wants its negative review removed from our site.

Career / Work category photographCareer / Work

A customer left a two-star review on the review section of our own website after an order arrived late. The team has since sorted out the order and agreed a refund. My manager has asked me to remove the review because the problem is now resolved.

I maintain that section of the site. The review describes the original delay accurately, and it isn't abusive. I can see why the business wants customers to know it put things right, but deleting the account of the delay feels different from adding that context.

We're a small company in England. We don't have a clear policy for what happens to reviews after complaints are settled. What should I ask the manager to decide before removing this one? Would a dated response or inviting the customer to update their review be a fairer way to show the full sequence?

Discussion

5 community replies

The CMA's guidance for businesses publishing reviews covers misleading review information and the need for review-handling policies and processes. It doesn't settle every moderation decision from a short description. Ask for the reason and policy governing removal here, rather than assuming that resolving a complaint automatically makes the original review inaccurate.

A dated business response could explain that the team has addressed the issue, using only details appropriate to share publicly. You could also invite the customer to add an update without making that a condition of resolving their complaint.

I'd ask how the same rule would apply across reviews. If the site removes only negative accounts once the business responds, what picture will readers get? Put that question to the person responsible for the review process before treating this as a one-off edit.

Isn't the unamended review misleading too, if a reader thinks the customer is still waiting for the order? The manager has a reasonable concern about an incomplete story.

Yes, the sequence needs context. An update or response can address the present status while preserving what the customer actually experienced. Ask which information is now wrong or missing and how to correct that specifically. “The complaint was settled” isn't, on its own, an explanation of why the original delay should disappear.

Join the discussion

Useful guidance

Describe one observable problem, explain its effect on the work and ask for a specific next step. Choose a suitable time and keep a factual record. Consider formal channels sooner when the issue involves safety, serious misconduct or a power imbalance.

How to prepare for a difficult conversation at work →

More in Career / Work