Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Career / Work · Advice & Questions ·

I wait until a proposal looks finished before sharing it, then resent the big changes

Career / Work category photographCareer / Work

I spent two weeks making a proposal for a customer welcome pack look convincing before showing it to sales and service colleagues. They immediately questioned who it was for and whether a pack was the right way to help those customers.

I was upset that they wanted to undo so much work. I also realised I had asked them to comment only after I had made the choices they needed to discuss. My manager wants me to show the next proposal earlier. I worry a rough draft will invite a dozen contradictory preferences before I have worked out what I think.

How can I invite useful early challenge without making every unfinished thought a team decision? I want to stop treating feedback as welcome only when it leaves the main idea intact.

Discussion

5 community replies

The early version does not need finished pages. Share the customer problem, the approach you are considering and the assumption you most need checked. Sales and service can then question the purpose before you invest in a polished solution. That is a more useful invitation than “any thoughts?” on everything at once.

You can ask for input and retain responsibility for a recommendation. Tell colleagues which decisions are open, what their perspective can help with and who will make the final choice. Hearing contradictory views does not oblige you to combine them into a proposal nobody intended.

There is an uncomfortable loss here: polish can make a draft feel ready to be judged, while early feedback exposes the thinking before it feels secure. Give yourself room to find that awkward. The practical change is to share an unresolved question deliberately, not pretend the rough work is already settled.

Not everyone needs to review every version. In this case sales and service had knowledge about the customers and the proposed use. A wider invitation to comment on the design at the same stage could add noise before the central question is answered.

Choose the reviewers for the decision you need to make now. Ask sales and service about the customer need and the proposed format; bring in other perspectives when they can change the relevant choice. Explain what you decided after that input so a focused review does not feel like comments disappearing into a draft nobody sees again.

Join the discussion

More in Career / Work